That jingle of coins in your pocket may be worth more than you realize. While many of us dump our loose coinage into jars or break it out for vending machines, some common coins could be sitting on far more value than you realize.
Day after day, Americans unknowingly transport potential fortunes in their wallets and coin purses. From mistakes made in manufacturing to limited mintages, these otherwise ho-hum pieces of metal can sometimes fetch thousands — or even millions — of dollars from collectors.
The Gold Mine in Your Pocket
John Flanagan never expected his design for the Washington Quarter would eventually make someone out there a millionaire. But in 2019, a Nevada contractor who cleaned out his truck’s ashtray found a 1932-D quarter worth $35,000.
In the same year, a 1969-S Lincoln penny with a doubled die obverse turned up in a Michigan teacher’s change jar — which was sold at auction for $22,800.
“People don’t think twice about their pocket change,” says Eleanor Ramirez, a numismatist who has spent three decades appraising rare coins.
“That’s exactly what ensures these treasures keep circulating. “The average person just doesn’t know what to look for.”
About $10 billion in collectible coins now circulate as everyday cash, according to the American Numismatic Association.
The most valuable specimens tend to come into circulation after collectors die and their heirs, who may not know the coins’ value, use them like ordinary currency.
The Fantastic Seven — Riches Of Seven Coins
1. 1943 Copper Penny (Worth: $100,000 – $1.7 million)
During World War II, the U.S. Mint issued pennies made of zinc-coated steel to preserve copper for the war effort.
But a small number of copper planchets from 1942 showed up in the 1943 output, yielding about 40 copper pennies that year. One fetched $1.7 million in 2010.
Of my grandfather, Mary Contrera of Phoenix remembers, “He had one in his drawer for decades, believing it was just an oddity. We had it authenticated after his death — “It paid for my daughter to go to college.”
2. 1955 Double Die Penny (Value: $1,000 — $114,000)
A die-clashing defect generated an estimated 20,000 pennies with a dramatic double effect on the date and lettering. While some were intercepted before they entered circulation, many made their way into the money supply.
Today, even in moderately worn condition, these pennies fetch four-figure prices.
“I’ve found three myself in bank rolls in my collecting lifetime,” says Thomas Wilkins, a coin dealer from Oregon. “The last one was used for a new roof for my house.”
3. 1982 No Mint Mark Roosevelt Dime (Value: $30 to $300)
Some 1982 pennies made at the Philadelphia Mint were inadvertently stamped without the mint mark.
And while they’re not worth quite as much as other entries on this list, they’re far more common, with thousands likely still to be in circulation.
4. 1992 Close AM Reverse Penny (Worth: $20,000+)
The pennies pictured above have the letters “A” and “M” as they appear in the word “AMERICA” on their reverse, and they both appear to differ from whatever the standard alignment is supposed to be.
The letters are closer together than average, and while this is a small but helpful variant that most people ignore,
5. 2004-D Wisconsin State Quarter Extra Leaf (Value $100 — $1,500)
This state quarter contains what defines an additional corn leaf on the obverse design. The mistake wasn’t detected until the coins had been released to the banks.
These quarters can be worth as much as $1,500 depending on condition—not terrible for a quarter.
6. 2005-P “Speared Bison” Jefferson Nickel (Value: $50 – $400)
A die gouge created an unusual effect that looks like a spear running through the bison on the reverse of this nickel. The mistake went unnoticed in production, and these nickels circulated extensively before collectors caught on.
7. 1969-S Doubled Die Obverse Lincoln Cent (Value: $20,000 — $126,500)
Known as a “doubled die,” this penny was struck showing clear doubling on Lincoln’s portrait and then repeating that on the date, and only a few dozen examples of it are known to exist.
A pristine example sold at auction for $126,500 in 2008.
How Valuable Coins Get Circulated
The process by which rare coins re-enter the day-to-day stream of commerce often begins with estates, especially those of collectors.
Numismatically aware relatives, if there are any, have to deal with heirs who don’t know what they have, and might spend valuable examples. Bank tellers, who never encounter rare variants, hand out these coins with standard currency.
Robert Jennings, a former bank teller and current coin dealer, explains: “I had a widow once bring in her husband’s penny collection — to convert to bills.
I recognized some important dates and suggested I purchase them properly instead. Some were worth hundreds of dollars each.”
Other coins worth a fortune come from caches lost to time. Dave Buchanan, a construction worker, found a stash of pre-1965 silver coins while renovating a 1940s house in Tulsa.
“They appeared to be tucked away in a wall cavity — maybe they were someone’s emergency fund decades ago. I verified each one before cashing them. Two had been worth more than $1,000 apiece to collectors.”
The Thrill of the Hunt
For some, the quest for coins of value is not just a hobby — it is a passion. Some hobbies have grown increasingly popular, like coin roll hunting, where enthusiasts buy rolls of coins from banks and assess each piece.
She is 32 and works as an accountant in San Francisco Sarah Winters started coin roll hunting during the pandemic.
“I’ve discovered three 1955 wheat pennies, a 1942 Mercury dime, even a 1932-S Washington quarter, worth approximately $125. “The thrill of unrolling a new batch never gets old, it’s a treasure hunt that pays for itself.”
A lot of hunters specialize in denominations. Half dollars sometimes offer up silver examples, pre-1971, and penny rolls can have wheat cents, or even the odd Indian Head penny that somehow got stuck in circulation.
“I do about $500 worth of quarters a week,” retired postal worker James Dobson says.
“Even if I find nothing special, I just redeposit them and try again. But I did find a 1932-D Washington quarter worth $4,200 last year. One coin paid for years of my hobby.”
How to Spot Valuable Coins
Compared to stamp collecting or art investing, rare coin hunting has few overhead costs — the face value of the coins you are examining. Experts suggest looking at these indicators:
Strange mint marks: D (Denver) and S (San Francisco) marks often mean lower mintage than Philadelphia-fresh coins.
Errors and varieties: Look for doubling on lettering, off-center strikes or incorrect planchets (a penny struck on a dime blank, for example).
Important dates: Some years had reduced production numbers. There is, for instance, 1950-D Jefferson nickels, and 1955-S Roosevelt dimes to look for.
Silver content: Dimes, quarters and half dollars made in 1964 and earlier have 90% silver, making them worth more than the face amount.
Changes to composition: Switches between types of metals often created valuable variants, such as the 1943 copper pennies or 1982 small-date copper cents.
The author of “Found Money: Discovering Rare Coins in Circulation,” Michaela Ruiz, advise using a jeweler’s loupe or magnifying glass. “Most valuable errors are subtle — doubled letters, repunched mint marks or small die cracks.
All the difference comes from good lighting and good magnification.”
Digital Age Challenges
New valuable varieties are less common nowadays, due in part to modern coin production methods that have caused error rates to drop considerably.
Also, grocery stores and banks often send odd specimens to automated coin counting machines for investigation, so they are removed from circulation.
“Time is getting short,” says veteran collector Harold Thompson. “Thirty years ago you could still find Mercury dimes and Buffalo nickels in your change.
These days, most pre-1965 silver has been lifted from circulation by determined seekers.”
Yet opportunities remain. The U.S. Mint is still putting billions of coins into circulation each year, and with that kind of volume, mistakes are bound to happen.
The 2019-W quarter program included quarters with the limited-edition West Point mint mark, which were placed directly into circulation and some of which are already bringing in premiums of $10-$20 each.
The Emotional Connection
Creating stories and connections, finding a rare coin transcends its monetary worth. Rebecca Chen: I have my grandma’s change jar and during my third-grade summer, I discovered a 1909 wheat penny in the jar.
Valuing only $3-$4, it ignited her lifetime passion for history and numismatics.
“Holding something that’s been handed over from hand to hand for over a century changes your perspective,” Chen says.
I wonder who had this penny in their pocket during World War I, the Great Depression, or the moon landing. That link to history is priceless.”
For Daniel Williams, finding a 1914-D Lincoln cent that is worth about $6,000 in a roll of pennies proved life changing. “That one coin bought my first semester of community college textbooks.
I changed my major to metallurgical engineering because I was fascinated in how they made these coins.”
Starting Your Own Hunt
Experts recommend starting with what is most plentiful and diverse — pennies. Check dates (particularly before 1959), search the reverse for wheat ears (1909-1958), and look for doubling in the lettering.
“Ask for rolls from smaller, rural banks where old coins may have been sitting in vaults longer,” says Patricia Simmons, a numismatist.
“And don’t forget about the coins you get back when you break a bill. I found a 1917 Buffalo nickel in gas station change last year.”
Whether you find a rare million-dollar coin or just enjoy the historical significance, searching your pocket change gives everyday purchases the potential for valuable finds.
The next time you hear a jingle of coins in your pocket, or purse, remember — you ll be carrying a small fortune in million-dollar pocket change.
ALSO READ: The $29 Million Coins Quest, Is Your Pocket Holding a Jackpot?